Recruiters are drowning in applicants. The ones they want aren’t in the water.

As I’m sure you already know, hiring is a mess right now.

Recruiters have application overload and still can’t find anyone to hire.

LinkedIn is processing around 11,000 applications a minute, 45% up on last year. UK graduate employers received 140 applications per vacancy for the second-year running, the highest since anyone started counting – which, if you’re interested, was 1991. Graduate roles in retail, FMCG and tourism hit 290.

You’d think more applicants would make hiring easier. Two-thirds of recruiters say it has got harder and more than half blame AI-generated CVs.

Nearly every CV now reads like it came from the same well-meaning intern. The same keywords in the same order. The same “proven track record of driving cross-functional alignment”. Candidates paste the job ad into AI and ask it to make them fit. AI obliges, because that’s what AI does. AI is very obliging.

Some pay AI agents to apply for hundreds of jobs. Recruiters respond by buying AI to screen out the AI. Candidates respond by buying better AI. Somewhere there are software vendors popping bottles of champagne.

Then there are the candidates who don’t exist. Gartner reckons one in four candidate profiles could be fake by 2028. Most of the fakes so far are turning up in cybersecurity and tech. Gartner may be wrong about the number but probably isn’t wrong about the direction.

So that’s the noise. Here’s what’s missing from it.

In most perm white-collar disciplines, around 70% of the people who could do the job are already doing it (or something similar) somewhere else. Some are less engaged than they used to be – but are still staying put.

Like everything else that seems to be accelerating at the moment – so is a lack of trust. And if we’re honest, it was already quite low.

Look at what they read every morning. Layoffs. Hiring freezes. Graduate vacancies down again. Five-stage interview processes that end in silence.

If you’re employed and not as engaged as you used to be, moving looks risky. Staying is dull – but dull isn’t as risky as leaving for a job that doesn’t look any different to the one you’re doing.

These people aren’t in your applicant pile. They only look at job ads occasionally (sometimes on purpose and sometimes by accident) and they’re not paying a bot to apply for 300 roles. They’re the people you want and the market has given them every reason to keep their heads down.

It seems to me that most of the industry has missed this. The response to the flood has been better filters and faster rejection – both of which are reasonable. But neither do anything about the 70% who never applied. A filter only works on what comes in and if the right person never entered the funnel, the cleverest screening tool on the market won’t find them.

A vague, requirements-led ad full of “fast-paced” and “competitive salary” gives an AI tool everything it needs to produce a matching CV. It gives an employed, cautious, half-interested person no reason to take a risk. That kind of ad serves one audience perfectly.

If moving feels risky, the ad should make it feel less so, without bullshitting.

  • Say what the role pays.
  • Say why people stay.
  • Say what they might learn.
  • Say what progression might look like.
  • Say who they’ll report to and how many were promoted last year.

Specifics reduce risk. Clichés increase that risk, because they suggest you’ve either got something to hide or nothing to say.

If an ad gets fewer applications, that’s good. The bots don’t care (or understand) what it says – but the people you’re trying to reach might.