Should recruitment agencies be bothered about the candidate experience?

Depending on what statistics you read, some 55% of applicants believe the standard of recruitment practice has declined.

I’m surprised it’s that low.

Creating a good candidate experience has become the latest trend in recruitment – there’s even an awards function dedicated to it. Or in other words, recruiters finding yet another excuse to dress-up and pat themselves on the back for not pissing-off as many people as their competitors.

The basic rationale behind creating a good candidate experience is that if candidates are treated well, they’ll think more positively of the company’s brand and talk about it to their friends, thus gradually making hiring easier.

But there’s one thing we need to get out of the way upfront, so we can put the whole candidate experience debate into some kind of context.

They hate all of it

Nobody likes being a candidate.

People find job-hunting extremely stressful and rarely ever relish the prospect of applying for jobs. It’s only marginally less stressful for people who don’t actually need another job, but are open to the possibility of getting a better one.

So in a business arena like recruitment that people dislike being a part of almost by default, how feasible is it to spend time and effort on improving something that candidates already hate? That seems about as pointless as reading a child a bedtime story whilst Nightmare On Elm Street is playing full blast on the TV.

How much time and effort do you really need to invest in improving the candidate experience if you’re on a hiding to nothing anyway? I’ll leave that for you to decide.

But if you do feel it’s important, let’s explore what the problems really look like and simple ways to resolve them.

Having a hiring process that creates a good candidates experience ranges from improving everything from job ads, career sites and applicant tracking systems through to responding to all CVs received and giving meaningful feedback to those candidates that were interviewed.

The last two are the only things candidates really care about, and paradoxically, are the two things that recruiters and hiring companies are reportedly the worst at.

So, what’s the answer?

That will depend on what type of recruiter you are. If you work inhouse, then your need for an improvement in this area is going to be different (and arguably more important) than those working agency side.

Let’s talk a closer look at agencies.

What kind of recruiter are you?

Again, your commitment to candidate experience will vary depending on whether you’re a temp agency or a perm agency.

Temp agencies are often placing the same people several times over and so managing a larger volume of applicants and all the associated admin should make their approach to this different to the perm recruiters.

It should also be noted that temp recruiters are often more able to be transparent about their client’s identity and, because they may have recruited for the same client many times before, will often have a better understanding of those jobs. That all contributes to them being better equipped to make the process less arduous for candidates.

Then we need to look at the different types of perm recruiters.

The generalist recruitment agencies tend to bother less with candidate experience because their supply chain of potential candidates is probably near to inexhaustible. This will be manifested by their constant need to find new clients because their candidate quality is usually somewhat inconsistent.

The niche specialists have an altogether different set of problems.

For them, their candidate pools are not inexhaustible and care does have to be taken to nurture positive relationships with people they could place in the future. They have to be more sensitive to their needs, if only because referrals are (or should be) a valuable source of new business.

In essence, the more niche the agency recruiter, the more critical candidate experience becomes.

The brand question

Then there’s the question of whether a bad candidate experience affects the agencies brand. That’s assuming they even have a brand that can be articulated – which most don’t.

Problems at the front end of a recruitment process (before the recruiter reveals who the hiring company is) tends to damage the agencies reputation. And problems at the back end (after the recruiter has revealed the company and arranged interviews) will damage both the agency’s and the hiring company’s reputation.

When candidates feel aggrieved by any aspect of the recruitment process, they tend to think that if a hiring company are this bad (or choose bad agencies to represent them), then they’re probably going to be bad to work for.

How a company recruits is often a window into their soul.

The bottom line is that in reality, most candidates are low-maintenance and do not have particularly high expectations when it comes to their job-hunting experience. They just need the adverts and job briefs to be accurate, the rejections to be prompt and the interview feedback to be as honest as legal compliance will allow.

So if you’re a recruitment agency and you want to improve the candidate experience, either for yourself or for your better clients, here’s my simple 3 step plan to help you achieve this:

1. Know a lot about the job, the company, their culture and their vision. This will come from either experience of past assignments, or by taking a really detailed brief and by asking some tough questions. This will have a huge impact on the quality of candidates you’re able to source and attract.

2. Produce job marketing that stands out from the crowd. Luckily this is quite easy. And make them easy to respond to.

3. Get back to all candidates when you say you’ll get back to them. If you haven’t given a time when you’ll get back to them, get back to them anyway. This is all most candidates want.

But remember, given that most people hate the process of finding a new job, the most you can realistically hope for is that candidates don’t also hate you.

If they don’t hate you (assuming they even remembered you), chances are they’ll talk to you again at some point in the future. And if people are always willing to talk to you, you’re in business.

In summary

Great candidate experience isn’t going to happen just by spending money on fancy websites, clever tech or building an employer brand – in fact I’d even argue that there is no such thing as a great candidate experience to anyone other than the person who ends up getting the job.

But it will happen by having great recruiters.

There are lots of differing definitions of what constitutes a great recruiter. For some it’s personality based and for others it’s about billing numbers.

I think the safest way to measure how good a recruiter is, is to look at the percentage of jobs they work on that they fill. A great recruiter fills around 80% and a not so great recruiter fills around 10%. The industry average across all agency recruiters is somewhere between 20% and 25%.

A decent candidate experience is, in all logical probability, just a by-product of decent recruiter managing the vacancy.


Sign up for my ‘Ad Lip’ newsletter for more stuff like this.