Attrition. What is it good for?

Attrition
/əˈtrɪʃ(ə)n/

noun: The process of reducing something’s strength or effectiveness through sustained attack or pressure.

Wearing down, wearing away, weakening, debilitating, enfeebling.

Agency recruitment has always lost a lot of the people it hires, and it loses most of them early. Ask any agency owner how many of last year’s trainees are still there.

Ask recruiters why and you’ll hear the same answers every time. It’s a tough job. Not enough training. An overly competitive culture. The job was mis-sold. Poor management. Weak selection. All of them have some validity.

The problem is, when addressed individually, none of these are likely to fix the issue. But let’s first look at the one I think is closest to the root of the real problem.

The job is difficult…

I’ve been in this industry for over 30 years. When I first stumbled into it in the pre-Internet age, the job was relatively straightforward – although it didn’t feel like it at the time. Being an agency recruiter today is more difficult than it’s ever been.

Job boards and LinkedIn democratised candidate information. Social media amplified everything. Corporate inhouse teams took a big chunk of the work. Now AI lets candidates apply for hundreds of jobs in an afternoon and lets recruiters send thousands of messages nobody reads.

Because of all this, many agencies have become more niche in the jobs they fill, and hiring companies have become narrower in the candidates they’ll consider.

The flood of hastily assembled job ads (and I’m being kind calling them ads) has made prospective candidates more jaded about whether any job could be better than the one they’re in.

Add more competition from other agencies on the same vacancies, and more of those jobs being filled by the client directly, and you get a job that’s more fractured and unpredictable than it’s ever been.

When the going gets tough…

Normally, when a market gets tougher to navigate, its suppliers raise their standards to meet the challenge. Not, it seems, in recruitment.

If I notice any behaviour pattern in this industry, it’s that it likes to play the numbers game.

Whether it’s a steady stream of badly written job ads, thousands of automated outreach messages (known to everyone else as spam) or 50 cold calls a week, it all points to an instinct that’s quantitative rather than qualitative. AI hasn’t changed that. It’s just made the numbers bigger.

And while we’re on numbers, there were more UK recruitment businesses in 2025 (31,345) than in 2023 (29,635).

Recruiters are drowning in applications from people they can’t place, the people they want aren’t applying, and inhouse teams have taken away a lot of the vacancies agencies used to fill. Yet the number of agencies keeps going up?

That would make more sense if those new agencies (most started, I assume, by people who used to work for other agencies) broke away because they wanted to do things differently. Some have, but they’re a small minority. Most are doing the same thing, in the same way, with the same clients.

It’s a bit like building a brand new house on condemned foundations. New business. Same broken model underneath.

And that broken model, ladies and gentlemen, is called contingency recruitment.

If standards are going to improve, it’s going to take more than better managers and better selection processes. And it won’t improve by training recruiters to get marginally better at the things candidates and clients are already fed up with.

Contingency recruiting is a legacy system…

The only way I can see industry standards improving is if all of the experienced recruiters start moving away from earning most of their money on contingency. By that I mean that they shouldn’t have to earn more than around 30% of their fees from working on ‘success only’.

And that means convincing most of their best clients to only use them and give them the platform to be able to deliver a service that most clients and candidates do want.

What clients want is better quality candidates and some kind of service guarantee.

The best kind of service guarantee a recruiter can give a client is the assurance that they will deliver the best possible candidates and that they will (all things being equal) fill their vacancy. That would be music to the ears of most hiring managers – and all they need to do to get it is to commit to one agency.

Because when a client commits to one agency supplier per vacancy, what they’re creating is the platform and the scope for the agency to do everything necessary to guarantee they’ll fill the job. That usually means superior job marketing and meaningful candidate screening/assessment – neither of which are currently happening – at least not in enough numbers for people to notice.

It isn’t happening because agencies are too busy only filling 20% of all the vacancies they work on to be able to do any of it as well as they could. It’s that numbers thing again.

All candidates want is greater transparency. That usually translates into more open and authentic job marketing and meaningful feedback on their application and any interviews they attend. That isn’t happening either because the recruiters are still too busy only placing around 1 in 20 candidates into the jobs they’ve pitched them via a job ad, email or phone call.

Numbers again. It always comes back to the fucking numbers.

Saying No…

I’ve sometimes been accused of being something of a militant when it comes to the debate between retained and contingency. I’m not, but I’ve yet to hear a rational explanation as to why a competent recruiter with many years experience and knowledge of a particular niche or sector would not be able to comfortably fill every single job they worked on in that niche.

All they would need to do to reach that state of nirvana would be to:

1. Sell the idea to the client.
2. Be selective with those that say “yes”.

That 2nd point is important.

Selling retained is much easier than you think. It just requires some forethought and patience.

But what is a little harder is politely saying “no” to those companies who don’t give the recruiter a robust job brief, a realistic expectation of the types of candidates they can attract and the scope to put out better quality job marketing. Recruiters aren’t known for their ability to say “no” to work – especially retained work.

But if you produce more income from fewer clients, the quality of the actual recruitment work goes up, as does the reputation of the agency along with the quality of their internal hiring processes and training needs.

And if all of those things go up, so too should the calibre of trainees hired by these agencies – because they’ll be learning the job (for the 1st year at least) supporting a recruiter who is achieving an 80-90% fill rate.

Those trainees can then spend their 2nd and 3rd years cutting their teeth on contingency before being taught how to slowly migrate their perm desk towards retained. The business they generate on contingency will be useful retained leads for the senior recruiters.

There’s your career expectations, job satisfaction and staff attrition problems at least partly solved. I don’t know what to do about the “poor management” part of the puzzle.

Same quantity, better quality…

When a recruiter has to work for free competing with several other agencies (and in some cases with the actual client as well), they’ll look for ways to make that daunting task a little easier.

Unsurprisingly, that means playing the numbers game – otherwise known as working on as many jobs as possible to increase the odds the recruiter will hit or beat target.

It’s impossible to consistently deliver a quality service when you’re competing with several other agencies all doing the same things, usually just as badly, which ironically just makes each of their jobs incrementally harder.

Recruiters who get good at playing the numbers game and quickly build a perm desk to say, £250K per year, can’t do that for ever by spot-trading candidates on the fringes of other people’s recruitment processes. They will at some point, between 3 and 6 years probably, burn out.

And where do burnt-out agency recruiters go? Into management usually. Or, if they’ve saved enough of that “big biller” money, they go inhouse.

So, if you wouldn’t build a new house on condemned foundations, why would you expect a recruitment model built for the pre-Internet era to hold up in a market that’s been rebuilt twice since – once by the Internet and again by AI?

So there’s my answer to the recruiter attrition problem. Make the job easier (and more logical), attract better candidates (who will see genuine career progression) and make the environment less competitive.

Should other people’s careers be distilled down to a spot-trading activity where “deals” are announced by ringing a bell and celebrated by going on piss-ups to Ibiza?

I’ll leave you to answer that before deciding what to do next.